Average nut quality of test trees 2002-2011.

Cultivar Yield #Nuts/lb. %Kernal Cluster Size Harvest Date
  lbs./tree/year       (50% shuck split)
Desirable 15.9 44 52% 2.5 Oct. 14
Stuart 15.9 47 45% 2.6 Oct. 20


Average pest resistance of test cultivars 2002-2011.

Cultivar Leaf ScabZ Nut ScabY Black Aphid DamageX Sooty Mold BuildupW
  Avg. (worst)V Avg. (worst) Avg. (worst) Avg. (worst)
Desirable 1.9 (4.0) 2.3 (4.4) 1.6 (2.7) 1.1 (2.0)
Stuart 1.4 (2.8) 1.1 (3.5) 2.2 (3.8) 1.1 (2.0)
  • Z 1=No scab, 2= Few stray spots, 3=Several spots with expanding lesions, 4=Stem scab or defoliation.
  • Y 1=No scab, 2=Few stray spots, 3=Obvious scab but no quality loss (0-10%), 4=10-50% shuck coverage, 5=50-100% covered, nut drop.
  • X 1=No damage, 2=Light spotting, less than 25% leaves affected, 3=Moderate spotting, 25-75% leaves, 4=Heavy spotting, >75% leaves affected, some leaves completely yellow.
  • W 1=None, 2=Light, some black on few leaves, 3=moderate, black on most leaves, 4=Heavy, black flakes on leaves and stems.
  • V Average score over all years and average of worst year for each trait.

Average yield (pounds nuts per tree) of test cultivars each year from planting in 2002.

Cultivar # Trees 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 
Desirable 6 0 0 0 0.5 2.7 11.4 23.1 23.5 45.3 52.8
Stuart 5 0 0 0 0 0.6 7.1 20.0 29.8 53.6 48.3



Originated from a seed planted in 1874 by J.R. Lassabe in Pascagoula from seed obtained in Mobile, Ala. The property was purchased by Capt. E. Castanera and selected one seedling which was originally known as 'Castanera'. This tree was later propagated by Col. Stuart and offered commercially in 1892 as 'Stuart'. (Perhaps the name was changed because Stuart outranked Castanera? (Kenknight, 1970)


'Stuart' is the most widely known and widely planted cultivar in the Southeast and is used as a standard to measure other cultivars. Its production in 74 years (73 lbs/tree/year, 34 lbs kernel/tree/year) far exceeds that of any other cultivar of the same age. It did not reach this status until the 65th year. One of the oldest 'Stuart' trees had the advantage of being a corner tree and the other had the advantage of being an end tree; thus, these yields are greater than one would expect had they been inside the orchard. 'Stuart' is a medium-sized nut with mediocre kernel percent (46) and kernel grade, but percent fill and specific gravity are among the highest. Yield has been excellent and consistent under modern cultural practices. The cultivar lacks precocity.

Everyone in Georgia knows the 'Stuart' pecan. I hesitate to say this cultivar is no longer recommended because it has many loyal devotees and still makes up a sizable portion of the commercial acreage. However, 'Stuart' has some important drawbacks. Overall, I feel that nut quality of 'Stuart' is marginal in most years, especially in comparison to newer cultivars. 2010 was a good example of this, Stuart had a percent kernel of 43%, while 'Zinner' with nearly the same yield was 59%. We have trouble with this cultivar not filling well, and in those cases the kernel is often dry with a fair amount of fuzz adhering to the surface. Yellow aphids like this cultivar and if they are not controlled, the honeydew builds up on leaf surfaces leading to sooty mold which seems to adhere particularly well on 'Stuart' leaves. 'Stuart' is supposed to be an early variety, but often the shucks fail to open properly, and 'Stuart' is often one of the latest varieties that we harvest. 'Stuart' is scab susceptible, but it is easier to control on scab on 'Stuart' than it is on 'Desirable'. An orchard of mature 'Stuart' trees can be profitable, but I would not recommend anyone plant more of this variety.

Production record of test trees beginning in year planted

'Stuart' production from the Old Variety Test. Each colored line represents the yearly production in pounds of nuts from an individual tree beginning the year planted.

Alternate Bearing Intensity* = 0.47

*Computed from mature trees using data from years after trees began receiving fertilizer and pesticide sprays.